• Banner 1

Welcome to Nice Guys Pizza

Nice Guys Pizza in Cape Coral, FL offers a unique blend of cocktail bar ambiance, dive bar charm, and delicious pizza. With a vast array of vegan and vegetarian options, this women-owned establishment caters to all dietary preferences. The eclectic decor and friendly atmosphere make it a must-visit spot, with live music on Wednesdays, Fridays, and Saturdays. Dive into their creative pizzas like the elote pizza or Washington Carver with peanut sauce for a flavor explosion. Don't miss out on their specialty drinks and appetizers like cool ranch tots and fried cheese, making Nice Guys Pizza a true culinary gem in the heart of Cape Coral.

Nice Guys Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Osman C.
Osman C.

Nice guys is hands down one of the most intriguing restaurants in all of Cape Coral. Their interior design, specifically for the holidays was elaborate and just so well done. Their drinks are top notch and always themed. Their apps and pizzas are amazing as well. We started with the cool ranch tots and received SIX dipping sauces! Most homemade! Highly recommend nice guys to anyone willing to make the drive.

Danielle B.
Danielle B.

Nice Guys Pizza is such a fun place! The atmosphere was fun with great music, interesting decor (so much to look at!), and friendly people. I liked that they had interesting mocktails. Not sure if that's for Dry January or always on the menu, but I ordered the Santa mocktail, which had interesting ingredients (pumpkin and pistachio), and it was great! We ordered the fried cheese, which were unlike any mozzarella sticks I've had before. They looked more like French Toast sticks, but there was melted cheese inside, and they were very good. There were so many pizzas we wanted to try, but we went with the elote pizza, which was great! I love corn and elote flavors, which I would recommend if you order this pizza. It was a pizza base with marinara sauce and cheese, which then had corn and elote sauce drizzle on top. We definitely would want to come back next time we're in town!

Brad E.
Brad E.

Great pizza restaurant. They have a separate vegan menu with some well thought out options. We got the pretzel bites appetizer and both of us absolutely loved it. We also got a general Gaos pizza and it was also really tasty. Great vibe along with great food! If you are a plant based eater head here.

Margaret M.
Margaret M.

October 2024 ~~ Awesome pizza place! The pizza, the drinks, the staff and the music was the bomb :) We got a pizza & wings & two drinks. Pizza - Washington Carver with peanut sauce, bacon, jam, mozzarella & provolone - loved every inch ! Also the Cajun Honey Butter BBQ wings - amazing . Drinks - Enemy Of Tradition Martini :)

Camrie C.
Camrie C.

The restaurant is so fun, full of art on the walls, the servers were SO nice, and our food didn't take long. My food was amazing, I got the vegan wings and vegan blue cheese My partner and friends obsessed over their "crunchy on the outside, melt in your month inside" wings, the garlic knots they were dying over, and the pizzas were fire! This place is a must try

Lynn U.
Lynn U.

Another bartender recommended this place in Cape Coral, so we decided to give it a try. Visually entertaining, good rock music, great service and delicious food. We had a meat lover's pizza. Pizza was hot with a lot of yummy toppings. Tried one of their delicious cocktails created by Zach, called Enemy of Tradition - a coffee martini with Parmesan foam. It was delicious and had wonderful coffee flavor. Conversation with Zach and Frampy was fun and interesting. We will be back to try more pizza topping combinations and more creative cocktails. This place is a great find.

Lauren O.
Lauren O.

Such a cool place, all about the vibes!! There's so much to look at and I love the black lights. The cocktail menu is also very cool. I got a gingery cocktail because they make their own ginger beer, VERY gingery too much for me but still good. I'd try a different cocktail next time. We also got the ranch tots, a pepperoni pizza and I got the bao buns platter. Hmmmmm go for the cocktails/beer and the tots. The pizza was insanely greasy and you couldn't even hold it and is that type of pizza, not my preference. I also thought the bao buns themselves were good but all the fillings lacked flavor, especially the meat. I'd still come back a million times over because this place is just so cool!! Friendly and fast service.

Anna L.
Anna L.

Stopped into Nice Guys Pizza for a quick bite while visiting family in Cape Coral this past weekend. My fam loves this place, so my husband & I decided to give it a try. We were starving after a long day of driving and setting up for an event. It was a Saturday night, and while they were pretty busy, we were still able to be seated right away. It's nice to see that the Cape has gained some pretty cool local spots since I last lived here 14+ years ago. This place has a fun, eclectic vibe with quirky decor and colorful lights. Since the parking is behind the building, the main entrance is through the back where you're welcomed by bright neon murals in a black-lit hallway. Service was quick and I was happy to see some mocktail options on the menu. I started with the non-alcoholic negroni and the garlic knots. These are smaller than you're typical garlic knots, but they're served in a big generous pile with a side of marinara for dipping. They were super fluffy and delicious. We were sooo hungry and these really hit the spot. Their dough really seems to be the star of the show here. If you enjoy super soft, fluffy pizza crust, then you'll love their style of pizza. They have many unique signature pizza combinations, but we went with a more simple one -- the Hot Honey pizza which is topped with salami, prosciutto, garlic, tomato, and hot honey. Our eyes were certainly bigger than our stomachs in this moment because we ordered the medium 14" but the small would have been plenty for the 2 of us. Oh well, it made for great leftovers the next day!

Location

  • Nice Guys Pizza
    1404 Cape Coral Pkwy E Cape Coral, FL 33904 Hotline: (239) 549-7542

Located in Cape Coral, Florida, Nice Guys Pizza is more than just your average pizza joint. With a diverse menu that includes vegan options, a full bar, and a fun, hipster-friendly atmosphere, this restaurant has something for everyone.

Nice Guys Pizza is not your typical pizza place. In addition to serving up delicious pies with unique toppings like peanut sauce, bacon, and jam, they also offer a separate vegan menu with well-thought-out options. The pretzel bites appetizer and the General Gaos pizza come highly recommended by guests, showcasing the restaurant's dedication to quality and flavor.

The lively atmosphere at Nice Guys Pizza is enhanced by the eclectic decor, friendly staff, and great music. Customers rave about the fun and welcoming vibe, making it a perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or family. The extensive list of amenities, including outdoor seating, pool table, and drive-thru option, means there is no shortage of entertainment or convenience at this establishment.

With rave reviews from satisfied customers praising the unique cocktails, appetizers like Cool Ranch Tots, and specialty pizzas such as the Elote pizza, Nice Guys Pizza is a standout destination in Cape Coral. Whether you're a plant-based eater looking for delicious vegan options or a pizza lover seeking innovative flavors, Nice Guys Pizza has something to offer every palate. Don't miss out on this gem the next time you're in town!